Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Lord Al

Why did the Voldemort send death eaters to enter Hogwarts

Recommended Posts

Lord Al

For what purpose did the death eaters enter Hogwarts
deatheasters.thumb.jpg.d4ea31ebd2bad6d06fba532fd55c2035.jpg

Hello HP fans,

 

I’ve been a big Harry Potter fan over the years and generally find the plots and stories very consistent throughout the 7 books. However, I cannot fathom why the death eaters decided to enter hogwarts at the end of the book. Why would Voldemort just allow his followers to enter the castle knowing full well dumbledore would eventually return from his travels. After all they have no idea that when he does return he would be in a weakened state and the DE’s normally would flee the fight when he inevitably enters the battle (as they did at the end of OOTP). Furthermore, why on earth would they set off the darkmark alerting dumbledore to there presence. Again, why would anyone assume the old man is not going to return with his full strength and with a rage upon him after seeing the mark in the sky. 

 

Also so on a final note, did Voldemort not find it strange that dumbledore was in such a weakend state (after all he would of heard the full account from Draco) surely he must of pondered what had put dumby in such poor state

 

Hopefuly someone one can help me out here. Thanks 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dumbledore

Hi @Lord Al and what a great set of questions to ask, firstly welcome to our community and thank you so much for joining.

 

I’ve made a note of these questions and I’ll answer them the best I can a little later, in the mean time if anyone else can share the love and answer them please do as we can open a discussion about it all and share our finding and reasonings. :hogwarts::glasses::default_biggrin:

  • Thumbs Up 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dumbledore

Right I have a couple of hours now, so I'll see if I can answer this the best I can!

  • Thumbs Up 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dumbledore

Hi @Lord Al I've finished writting up this essay! :default_rofl:

 


The deatheaters didn't know that Dumnledore was weakened, it was just that his hand was. It just so happened that Snape had mentioned it to Bellatrix at Spinner’s End. They may have known also from Draco too. So the deatheasters just assumed he'd left the castle and gone to Hogsmeade. Presumably they hoped to get into place and then catch him on his way back - they must have had a lookout posted, and that was how they knew he'd landed on the Astronomy Tower.

We've got to remember that Snape was working for Dumbledore and passing information to Lord Voldemort, with Dumbledore knowing that Draco was up to something, and that he was behind the botched attacks that mistakingly hit Ron and Katie Bell.
But finding out he had been working on repairing the broken Vanishing Cabinet so that he could use it infiltrate Hogwarts was news to him. With that in mind
there was also the likelihood that Voldemort would get control of Hogwarts. Voldemort only wanted 'pure blood' students at the School just like Salazar Slytherin (who wanted to be more selective of the students).

Draco also had a lot riding on his shoulders too, with Voldemort at the family manor he may be thinking that he needs to come through with what was dealt with him to protect his family. As to the night itself, Dumbledore didn’t know the Death Eaters would enter Hogwarts, nor Bellatrix Lestrange, Fenrir Greyback, and the others. He would never have placed the students in his care in such danger if he knew that was a possibility. He knew Draco’s assignment was to kill him, and allowed Draco to proceed without knowing that Dumbledore was onto him. He had hoped that Draco would realise that he is not a killer, that he would ultimately make the right choice and certainly didn’t know that a bloodbath would erupt. Dumbledore had orchestrated his death to be at the hands of Snape, this was to save the power of the Elder Wand which Snape was not aware of, and to not taint Draco Malfoy's soul. He just wasn't aware of the timing of Voldemort's plan the night he died. Had he known that the Death Eaters would have infiltrated Hogwarts that night, he might not have left to find the Horcrux at all. 

We also know that Voldemort wasn't always the smartest, especially in Dumbledors eyes. Let us not also forget that Voldemort was so confident in his own prowess that he did not, even in his wildest dreams think that someone would know about his Horcruxes. He is very clearly arrogant. He believes that he knows the most about Hogwarts and its secrets and that he has gone further than any other wizard on the path to immorality. His arrogance makes him believe that no one could possibly figure out that he has not just 1 but 7 horcruxes.

As for the dark mark, this is clearly arrogance again (showing off) and that he, Voldemort, could get past all the protections put in place to protect Hogwarts and it's students.

 

I hope this helps you and anyone else, if you need me to elaberate on anything then let us know!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lord Al

I fear we may have to go back and forth on this topic 😂, but looking forward to it. 

 

I pretty much agree with all of your above statement.

 

Dracos motives are clear and simple to me... desperation. I always took it that He lured dumbledore to the tower in the hope of having a face to face with him. Draco understood he could never defeat dumbledore so was secretly hoping dumbledore would disarm him, show mercy and help him. the fact he disarmed dumbledore was a surprise to him which is why he was so stumped and unsure what to next in their exchange.

 

Where I’m completely missing the point, is the strategic plan behind sending death eaters into castle. What was the goal?As far as we know the goal of Draco killing dumbledore was merely punishment for Lucius’ past failures. Why would Voldemort sign off on such a mission?. voldemort was only arrogant in his own abilities... so many times we were told voldy trusted no one else. So why send your own troops into battle with the (2nd according to voldy) greatest wizard of the time without a real goal or reason. Hope this helps clarify my question. Thanks 🖖🏼

 

 

  • Thumbs Up 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lord Al

Also to pick up your point regarding dumbledores blackened hand. I’m not sure what info would have fed back to Voldemort, but I’m sure no one would’ve told Voldemort  dumbledore is in a compromised state because of it.

Also this has just sprung to mind. Surely Voldemort would remember what curses he placed around and on his horcruxes and what damage they would inflict upon the drinker and wearer.

 

If we are going on purely his arrogance, would he not think... dumbledore is 2nd only to himself, therefore by default only curses and spells that Voldemort had created could defeat and destroy dumbledore.

no I’m not saying he would jump to the conclusion that his horcruxes were in danger. But wouldn’t he think... wow, dumbledore sure is showing symptoms of my kind of dark curses and spells 🤔😂.

Happy reading 👍🏼

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dumbledore
4 minutes ago, Lord Al said:

But wouldn’t he think... wow, dumbledore sure is showing symptoms of my kind of dark curses and spells 🤔😂.


I don't really know, JKR hasn't really gone into it... I'll shall have to have a word with a few potter heads and see what we can come up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lord Al

Thanks headmaster lol. I don't have any HP fans as friends so never had anyone to ask these questions to. Hopefully we can get some help .

Thanks again

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dumbledore
1 minute ago, Lord Al said:

Thanks headmaster lol. I don't have any HP fans as friends so never had anyone to ask these questions to. Hopefully we can get some help .

Thanks again

And that's what our forum is about, bringing people together and their love of Harry Potter.

I'd have to sit down and seriously think about this as I haven't had a question like this and it's quite interesting to think about all these details.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dumbledore

@roroweasley you seem to be very knowledgeable, how would you best describe he-who-must-not-be-named actions with infiltrating Hogwarts? 

 

@Lord Al has me stumped on the best way to answer this! 🤣

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dumbledore
On 05/09/2019 at 20:41, Lord Al said:

Also to pick up your point regarding dumbledores blackened hand. I’m not sure what info would have fed back to Voldemort, but I’m sure no one would’ve told Voldemort  dumbledore is in a compromised state because of it.

But all we know is that his hand is blacked and I don't think anymore was thought about it, or at least to no concern to those supporters. Hence why it was never really mentioned.

 

On 05/09/2019 at 20:26, Lord Al said:

Where I’m completely missing the point, is the strategic plan behind sending death eaters into castle. What was the goal?

If you send them in they can take control of Hogwarts. it's the only wizarding school in the UK. With that in mind, Voldemort can select the teachers and only take pupils of pure blood status. As Voldemort tried to get a teaching post at Hogwarts but was denied by Dumbledore. He knew he had other intentions.

 

On 05/09/2019 at 20:41, Lord Al said:

Also this has just sprung to mind. Surely Voldemort would remember what curses he placed around and on his horcruxes and what damage they would inflict upon the drinker and wearer.

Maybe so, but it isn't explored so we can only guess?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kaedequinn

I always assumed the reason the Death Eaters were there was because Voldemort didn't believe Draco would actually kill Dumbledore, and maybe they were sent there to report back to Voldemort. Draco could have easily told Voldemort he'd killed Dumbledore after Shape had if the Death Eaters hadn't been there, and therefore would have saved himself from possibly being killed by Voldemort. I feel like they were as proof.

Also, Voldemort loved killing people, and the Death Eaters did too, so I imagine for them seeing Dumbledore,  who was Voldermort's biggest enemy, die would have been a great spectator sport for them!

As for the Dark Mark. Didn't they only cast that after Dumbledore was dead? If so it was probably done as a victory type thing

  • Thumbs Up 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lord Al
4 hours ago, kaedequinn said:

I always assumed the reason the Death Eaters were there was because Voldemort didn't believe Draco would actually kill Dumbledore, and maybe they were sent there to report back to Voldemort. Draco could have easily told Voldemort he'd killed Dumbledore after Shape had if the Death Eaters hadn't been there, and therefore would have saved himself from possibly being killed by Voldemort. I feel like they were as proof.

Also, Voldemort loved killing people, and the Death Eaters did too, so I imagine for them seeing Dumbledore,  who was Voldermort's biggest enemy, die would have been a great spectator sport for them!

As for the Dark Mark. Didn't they only cast that after Dumbledore was dead? If so it was probably done as a victory type thing

 

Hi Kaedequinn,

 

Thanks for joining the thread.

 

I suppose my thoughts in a  nutshell are.... All of these plans to infiltrate Hogwarts would be perfect if they'd have known Dumbledore was in poor health. But they didn't... so there is no reason to assume they would be successful in a fight fight with him.  Only a year back they tried to flee when he arrived at the ministry and he still managed to single handedly capture most of the DE's and then hold his own (even at his age) in a dual with Voldemort himself. 

 

Many thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lord Al
Just now, Lord Al said:

 

Hi Kaedequinn,

 

Thanks for joining the thread.

 

I suppose my thoughts in a  nutshell are.... All of these plans to infiltrate Hogwarts would be perfect if they'd have known Dumbledore was in poor health. But they didn't... so there is no reason to assume they would be successful in a fight fight with him.  Only a year back they tried to flee when he arrived at the ministry and he still managed to single handedly capture most of the DE's and then hold his own (even at his age) in a dual with Voldemort himself. 

 

Many thanks

Also if you remember. The Dark mark was what caused Harry and Dumbledore to rush back to the castle on the brooms

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kaedequinn
10 hours ago, Lord Al said:

Also if you remember. The Dark mark was what caused Harry and Dumbledore to rush back to the castle on the brooms

Ah ok. I've not read the books and only seen the movies. In the movie the Dark Mark is cast after Dumbledore was killed.

I don't think anyone knew he was in a weakened state. It's possible that Snape told Voldemort that Dumbledore was looking for Horcruxes and he guessed he'd find the locket, but I doubt it as the cave was designed so anyone trying to get the locket would die. I think the Death Eaters were told to go there by Voldemort, and when Voldemort tells you to do something, you do it. I think the reason the Death Eaters fled after the battle at the Ministy Of Magic was because if they'd caught they'd have ended up back in Azkaban. It was more likely they left so they could spare themselves, and I'm guessing they hadn't been told to fight Dumbledore

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • Dumbledore
      By Dumbledore
      Join Audible today and get your first four months for just £3.99 per month. Enjoy your choice of audiobook each month & unlimited Audible Original Podcasts.
       
      Harry Potter has never even heard of Hogwarts when the letters start dropping on the doormat at number four, Privet Drive. Addressed in green ink on yellowish parchment with a purple seal, they are swiftly confiscated by his grisly aunt and uncle. Then, on Harry’s eleventh birthday, a great beetle-eyed giant of a man called Rubeus Hagrid bursts in with some astonishing news: Harry Potter is a wizard, and he has a place at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. An incredible adventure is about to begin!

      Audible is £3.99/month for the first four months and £7.99/month thereafter. Renews automatically. Cancel anytime.
      Return to Hogwarts today!
       

      Join Audible today and enjoy 50% discount for the first 4 months
      Enjoy 50% discount in the first 4 months, then only pay £7.99/month. You'll get 1 book credit each month to purchase any audiobook of your choice. Take your pick from the world's largest selection, regardless of price, including the latest best sellers. Download the free app and your audiobook will be waiting in your library. Just press play and enjoy.  
      TAKE ADVANTAGE OF 50% OFF NOW
       
      Why become an Audible member?
      You own your audiobooks Your books are yours to keep, even if you cancel. Swap an audiobook for any reason Exchange any book, any time. Free Audio Shows Unlimited listening to original podcasts for members. Exclusive deals throughout the month Up to 80% off selected audiobooks. Listen online or offline Enjoy when you’re online, underground or mid-flight.  
      JOIN NOW!
       
      Don't forget after your trial you can pick up the rest of the series! Remember, you're not only limted to Harry Potter, this covers various books offered by Audible!
       

      Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Book 1
      https://amzn.to/2CQDe7J
       

      Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Book 2
      https://amzn.to/2CQW4eW
       

      Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Book 3
      https://amzn.to/2CSiQ5V
       

      Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Book 4
      https://amzn.to/2rY1tPf
       

      Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Book 5
      https://amzn.to/37fg7l7
       

      Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Book 6
      https://amzn.to/37hy1Uj
       

      Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Book 7
      https://amzn.to/340FEfJ
    • Dumbledore
      By Dumbledore
      Fantastic Beasts 3 is  to be released in two parts with the first one being set to release in sometime in November 2021 with Brazil’s Rio de Janeiro confirmed to be the main shooing location. J.K. Rowling herself teased last year. While we don’t yet know the exact year of the film’s setting, Rowling’s tweet indicates it will be during the 1930s.
       

       
      Set to return are:
      Eddie Redmayne as Newt Scamander Jude Law as Albus Dumbledore Johnny Depp as Gellert Grindelwald Ezra Miller (Credence / Aurelius Dumbledore) Alison Sudol (Queenie Goldstein) Dan Fogler (Jacob Kowalski) Katherine Waterston (Tina Goldstein)  
      Wizarding World (that replaced Pottermore), announced Fantastic Beasts 3 has been officially greenlit, “with production confirmed to start in Spring 2020.” There was also a report that the next movie may include a lot more of Hogwarts and Jude Law's Albus Dumbledore, which may have been a hint to the third movie adding more emphasis on what Harry Potter fans like.
       
      When will we see Fantastic Beasts 3 trailer?
      We probably won’t get a teaser until early 2021, with a full trailer following sometime after that.
    • Dumbledore
      By Dumbledore
      Harry Potter star Tom Felton has revealed he doesn't think the cast will ever reunite for any more instalments of the franchise. Tom has expressed along with  fans who don’t see the need to update the original franchise.
       
      Speaking to various sources, Felton was asked if he thought the cast would do another movie.
       
      "How much you offering?" he answered.
      "I'm joking. I don't think it will be reprised, to be honest with you.
      "I think it was a wonderful eight chapters, and everything that needed to be done was done. I think they'll take it further on in their own direction, but we're all still immensely proud to be part of it."
       
      The actor, who played Draco Malfoy, also added that he was happy to see how the Potter fandom is still growing.
       
      "It's great to see it's been past down from generation to generation," Tom said. "But I can speak for the cast when I say we're very grateful for all of the support that's come our way over the last decade."
       
      Tom shared a photo of himself standing beside a pic of Draco Malfoy from the first Harry Potter movie, The Philosopher's Stone, and poked fun at how much he's changed over the years.
      Pointing at the poster of young Draco while also wearing a Slytherin cape, Tom wrote: "Agings a bitch".
    • Dumbledore
      By Dumbledore
      Head back to Platform 9 3/4, climb aboard the Hogwarts Express and enjoy the Complete Harry Potter Collection for a magical price. Presented in a gorgeous slipcase, these editions of J. K. Rowling's classics come complete with stunning cover illustrations from Jonny Duddle.
       


      A phenomenon like no other, Harry's incredible journey begins with The Philosopher's Stone. Unhappily living in a cupboard under the stairs at his aunt's, he's visited by a giant called Rubeus Hagrid who delivers the most astonishing news - Harry's a wizard. As he heads to Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Harry makes friends with Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger, meets oh-so-wise Professor Dumbledore and the complex Severus Snape and their incredible adventure begins. But evil in the shape of Lord Voldemort is getting ever closer - and the Dark Lord has his sights set firmly on Harry.

      Throughout the seven books, Harry learns what it means to be a Gryffindor student and the value of friendship and trust. The eight films starring Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint were a record-breaking success and now you can relive the stories where it all began time and time again with this amazing Harry Potter box set - Expecto Patronum!

      Includes
      Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Harry Potter and the Half-blood Prince  Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows  
      Promo Code:
       
      To Buy:
      https://www.thebookpeople.co.uk/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/qs_product_tbp?productId=580981

About Us

The Wizarding World | Harry Potter Fan Forums

A friendly and welcoming community for fans of Harry Potter! Quizzes, Earn Points For Your House, Competitions, Memorabilia, Fan Art, Fan Fiction, Pictures, Wallpapers and more!
TheWizardingWorld.co.uk is run by a group of dedicated enthusiasts on a not-for-profit basis.

Disclaimer

TheWizardingWorld.co.uk website are in no way affiliated with or endorsed by J.K. ROWLING WIZARDING WORLD which is a trademark of J.K. Rowling and Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc or any of it's worldwide subsidiaries or associates. Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts characters, names and related indicia are trademarks of and Warner Bros. Ent. All Rights Reserved..

Affiliate & Notice

TheWizardingWorld.co.uk is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com

Note: TheWizardingWorld.co.uk claims no credit for any images posted on this site unless otherwise stated. Images on this site belong to their respective owners. If there is an image on this website that belongs to you and you do not wish for it appear on this site, please e-mail us with a link to said image and it will be promptly removed..

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.